![]() The websites provided below may assist researchers in obtaining local court rules and forms. ![]() While the Law Library maintains a selective collection, there is no guarantee that the Law Library's materials are current. Court System Type: environmental cases, small claims cases, municipal court cases. “Specifically, the ALJ Decision supports Defendant’s position that the verdict of the jury was against the manifest weight of the evidence.Local court rules and forms should be obtained from the court. ![]() “The fact-finding and analysis contained in the ALJ Decision, issued after considering the same set of facts and nearly identical legal theories, is relevant to this Court’s consideration of three arguments contained in the Post-Trial Motions,” the motion reads. The latest dispute is over Stephens asking the court to consider a May 23 administrative law judge ruling in his favor on Edelstein’s EEOC claims. Failing those he is asking the judgement be reduced because punitive damages weren’t warranted and the back-pay amount was erroneous. Stephens has asked the judge to rule that the evidence did not support the $1.1 million verdict or grant a new trial. The federal court dismissed the county, Gmoser and Ferguson from the case in 2020.Įdelstein has appealed to the 6th Circuit Court, claiming among other things the county should still be on hook - and presumably financially responsible - in the lawsuit. ![]() She also claimed the county’s policy of allowing Christians to have Christmas off without taking a vacation day is discriminatory. Of the current total, county taxpayers have paid the county’s $100,000 insurance deductible.Įdelstein filed the $1 million lawsuit against Stephens, the county, Butler County Prosecutor Mike Gmoser and Chief Assistant Prosecutor Dan Ferguson in 2017, claiming Stephens fired her for wanting to take off eight Jewish high holy days and saying the men bad-mouthed her, destroying her career. The legal bills to defend the case through the end of April totaled $345,650, and continue to mount. Instructions and additional self-help resources are provided. Complete Ohio court forms using an interactive interview process completed forms can be saved and printed. Common Pleas Court Judge Greg Stephens has been fighting with his former magistrate Kimberly Edelstein over claims he fired her for being Jewish, and while she won a $1 million verdict in February the battle is ongoing. View and download forms for use in Butler County Area Courts. Explore Butler County legal bills for Jewish magistrate top $243,000Īnother federal employment action against Butler County judges has been going on for six years, and no end appears in sight. The other judges couldn’t be reached for comment.īutler County Prosecutor Mike Gmoser said “at this time” he has no comment. Gabbard claims nobody told her she hadn’t provided sufficient paperwork.Īrea III Court Judge Courtney Caparella-Kraemer told the Journal-News she could not comment on the lawsuit and in fact knew nothing about it prior to the federal court filing. ![]() The lawsuit claims Lovelace cited the following concerns in a termination letter: “1) Gabbard allegedly cleaned out her desk when she took leave 2) failed to return FMLA paperwork after allegedly being reminded and asked about it on several occasions and 3) failed to submit a request, in writing, to Lovelace along with a signed physician’s statement stating how long she needed to be off of work.” She alleges Court Administrator Linda Lovelace fired her in a letter dated Aug. The lawsuit claims prior to Gabbard’s leave her supervisor was “agitated” that she wanted to take longer than six weeks off and that she asked the county to provide her a place to express breast milk upon her return. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |